Antagonist training: Myths, dangers and benefits

You pull yourself up on tiny holds, train your fingers, and then diligently do opposing muscle exercises. All to give your elbow a rest. Good idea? Maybe. But your body isn't an accounting system: ten pulls, ten pushes, account balanced. Unfortunately, it's not that simple.

An essay by Klaus Isele, MSc, MSc.

The opponent is not an opponent

An antagonist is a muscle that can perform a movement in the opposite direction. At the elbow, for example, the brachialis flexes, while the triceps extends. When the movement changes, their roles also reverse. Therefore, the two are not opposing factions, but rather colleagues with different functions.

Fun Fact: The major exception is the scrotum in men, the testicles, which, as the only skeletal muscle (originating from the abdominal muscles), has only gravity as its antagonist.

In my work with climbers, I often hear: "My flexors are stronger than my extensors, so I need to train my extensors." Understandable. However, that's not a diagnosis. A difference in strength alone doesn't reliably determine the risk of injury – nor does it automatically identify the right exercise.

More muscle doesn't solve every problem.

When people think of antagonist training, they often think of strengthening first. I'm also interested in how the muscles work together: Can you build up tension appropriately, control the movement, and release it when needed? Or are you holding on tighter than the task requires?

The nervous system coordinates muscle activity. One mechanism is called reciprocal inhibition: activating one muscle can inhibit the activity of its antagonist. However, the antagonist isn't simply switched off. Depending on the task, both muscles contract simultaneously, for example, to stabilize a joint. A rigid "you on, me off" approach would be quite impractical, especially when climbing a wall. The opposing muscle on the other side helps me stabilize my wrist at the right angle, allowing me to grip the next hold optimally and transfer the necessary force through my fingers.

Antagonist training doesn't automatically mean that the opposing muscle is too weak and needs to grow larger. The neuromuscular regulation between agonist and antagonist is more interesting. Terms like "balancing" or "joint centering" can describe this.

Alex Megos during cross-training, supported by Patrick Matros during a climbing trip in Margalef | Photos: P. Matros Archive

Will this protect me from injuries?

I'd love to sell you a resounding "yes." Three exercises, pain-free until retirement. Wouldn't that be fantastic? Unfortunately, it's not quite that simple. There is evidence that supplementary strength training programs can reduce shoulder and elbow injuries in climbers. A systematic review from 2023 describes corresponding results but emphasizes the limited scope of research. Therefore, no blanket protective effect can be derived from this for every antagonist program. The more relevant question is: What exactly do you want this exercise to improve? Resilience? Mobility? Control under load? "Because that's what you do" is about as precise a training goal as "somewhere up high" is for route planning.

When is it used?

As a prophylactic measure

You don't have to wait until something hurts. If you repeatedly notice that one side reacts differently, that your muscles maintain tension for an unusually long time, or that you recover poorly between workouts, a professional assessment can be helpful. Biomechanical developments—for example, an increasingly forward-oriented shoulder position—can also be a reason to take targeted countermeasures if they actually restrict movement, resilience, or performance.

In the treatment

If pain is already present, exercise selection is part of the individualized treatment. Tennis elbow cannot be explained simply by labeling it an "antagonist problem." First, understand what's going on, then apply targeted stress. Don't work through the entire exercise library and then ask for a diagnosis.

How often, how much, and when?

Supplementary antagonist training should be performed submaximally. My practical starting point: End a set when you can still manage approximately three clean repetitions. Plan rest periods and volume according to your goal and capacity, and treat this session in your training plan like any other submaximal workout.

And one more rule: Climbing training should be complex in terms of coordination. Therapy and preventative measures, on the other hand, should be as simple and clear as possible. This allows them to be performed with fewer errors. So, you don't need a circus-like finale for a good supplementary exercise. Especially in the professional and semi-professional ranks, every additional training stimulus is also an additional load. Plan for this and don't underestimate this session. Think: Overtraining through compensatory training!

When should I seek help?

My experience is quite clear: those who ask early often only need a brief assessment or a single consultation. Those who wait until pain and limitations become apparent are more likely to end up in a longer rehabilitation or therapy process.

Unfortunately, our healthcare system is not very prevention-oriented. Therefore: it's better to ask too early than too late. Modern therapy can not only treat symptoms but also help to specifically optimize movement and performance. Be smart, beat the system!

So, to summarize briefly:

Can antagonist training improve my performance? In this specific case: yes.
Do my antagonists need to become stronger? No.

Your take-home points:

The interesting effect of antagonist training lies less in strengthening the opposing muscle group and more in its neuromuscular control. Put simply: when you contract your brachialis, your triceps doesn't just sit idly by. The nervous system regulates its interaction with the brachialis to ensure controlled movement.

Antagonist training does not automatically mean that the opposing muscle is too weak and therefore needs to become stronger. Rather, the crucial factor is the neuromuscular regulation between agonist and antagonist. Any observed effects can be traced back to this interaction.

Training and training management can be as complex as possible. In contrast, therapy and prophylaxis measures should be relatively simple, clear, and as error-free as possible.
Performing an antagonist training: Train submaximally and schedule it in the training plan like any other submaximal training session.

What does the evidence say?

AussageEvidence
My flexors are stronger than my extensors, so I do antagonist training.No
I do antagonist training to prevent injuries.No
Antagonist training serves to center the joint by balancing agonist and antagonist.Slightly Positive
Good antagonist training regulates the tension states between agonist and antagonist.Most likely

About the author: Klaus Isele

Klaus Isele works with climbers every day. For ten years, he traveled with the Austrian national climbing team and coaches numerous top athletes. Among his highlights is coaching Adam Ondra, particularly during the Silence project. Klaus is a physiotherapist, osteopath, sports osteopath, chiropractor, and climbing coach.


That might interest you

+ + +

Credits Cover image: Adobe Stock

News

Just be quiet for a moment – ​​Why wildlife sanctuaries are so important

A single sprint to escape through deep snow depletes chamois or ibex of reserves that cannot be replenished in the middle of winter. Wildlife sanctuaries in the Alps are designed to prevent this, so you should know these rules.

More than just a ring: Safety and tradition in Saxon Switzerland

The Elbe Sandstone Mountains are known (and infamous) for their strict climbing rules, created to protect the sandstone and preserve the adventurous nature of the sport. Even today, these rules remain at the heart of the debate between climbing integrity and safety.

Adam Ondra achieves the first ascent of "Huga Chaga" (9b+) in Arco

The Czech climber had actually bolted the line back in 2022, but then didn't attempt it again due to the birth of his son. Ondra now proposes a grade of 9b+ for "Huga Chaga," thus giving the Arco climbing area one of its hardest routes to date.

The Pou brothers complete their difficult trilogy on Peña Santa with "Relampagu" (8c/600 m)

Eneko and Iker Pou have completed the first ascent of their third difficult route on Peña Santa de Castilla (2.596 m). The project of the two brothers from the Basque Country dates back to 2020, when they established "Rayu" (8c/600 m), one of the steepest multi-pitch routes in the Picos de Europa.

Just be quiet for a moment – ​​Why wildlife sanctuaries are so important

A single sprint to escape through deep snow depletes chamois or ibex of reserves that cannot be replenished in the middle of winter. Wildlife sanctuaries in the Alps are designed to prevent this, so you should know these rules.

More than just a ring: Safety and tradition in Saxon Switzerland

The Elbe Sandstone Mountains are known (and infamous) for their strict climbing rules, created to protect the sandstone and preserve the adventurous nature of the sport. Even today, these rules remain at the heart of the debate between climbing integrity and safety.

Adam Ondra achieves the first ascent of "Huga Chaga" (9b+) in Arco

The Czech climber had actually bolted the line back in 2022, but then didn't attempt it again due to the birth of his son. Ondra now proposes a grade of 9b+ for "Huga Chaga," thus giving the Arco climbing area one of its hardest routes to date.

Comment on the article

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here